Past Queens
- 2023 Gracie Mitch
- 2022 Whitney Gudonis
- 2021 Aiyana Reed
- 2020 N/A
- 2019 Shawnna Bingaman
- 2018 Julia Nesbit
- 2017 Kaiya Reed
- 2016 Mahala Laub
- 2015 Deborah Thomas
- 2014 Michaela Weaver
- 2013 Tessa Bonson
- 2012 Kristijana Seler
- 2011 Hannah Jordan
- 2010 Korinne Bubb
- 2009 Casey Shawver
- 2008 Jade Gross
- 2007 Laken Fetterolf
- 2006 Trista Musser
Past Princesses
- 2023 Olivia Dormam
- 2022 Alaina Brower
- 2021 Caleigh Smith
- 2020 Dakota Kreis
- 2019 Whitney Gudonis
- 2018 Sarah Nesbit
- 2017 Aiyana Reed
- 2016 Kaiya Reed
- 2015 Olivia Laub
- 2014 Julia Nesbit
- 2013 Jaylynn Blair
- 2012 Brooke Aucker
- 2011 Deborah Thomas
- 2010 Tessa Bonson
- 2009 Gabrielle Vega
- 2008 Larissa Bubb
- 2007 Casey Shawver
- 2006 Jordan Fisher
Past Little Misses
- 2023 Lillian Kratzer
- 2022 Amarah Mulaney
- 2021 Josephine Boyd
- 2020 Alexis Smith
- 2019 Olivia Dorman
- 2018 Alaina Brower
- 2017 Maesyn Franquet
- 2016 MeKenna Franquet
- 2015 Sarah Nesbit
- 2014 Whitney Gudonis
- 2013 Kelsey Schuller
- 2012 Jaylynn Blair
- 2011 Gabriella Norman
- 2010 Gabrielle Walker
- 2009 Deborah Thomas
- 2008 Olivia Folk
- 2007 Brooke Aucker
- 2006 Samantha Hoffman
Past Teeny Beans
- 2023 Ensley Mitchell
- 2022 Charlotte Heeter
- 2021 Izzabella DeLong
- 2020 Lillian Kratzer
- 2019 Rylee Peterson
- 2018 Amarah Mulaney
- 2017 Olivia Dorman
- 2016 Tessa Stahl
- 2015 Alaina Brower
- 2014 Kylie Mitchel
- 2013 Brianna Hosler
- 2012 MeKenna Franquet
- 2011 Devin McAuley
Past Baby Beans
- 2023 VioletGrace Ortiz
Past Little Misters
- 2021 Camden Kreis